Comparison of Google Search vs. SEMrush vs. Ahrefs 2023

Having the best SEO tools are a necessary part of your business life.

But it’s confusing as to which tool is needed.

So I am going to help you navigate the waters by sharing which tool to choose. Let’s compare Google Search Console, Ahrefs, and SEMrush.

Here’s a quick overview of which tool may be suitable for you.

Keep reading for pros, cons and prices of each tool.

Google Search Console:

  • Want to monitor a websites performance in Google search results.
  • Focused on improving organic visibility.
  • Optimizing a website for better search engine rankings.
  • Identify and fix any crawling or index issues.
  • Looking for keywords driving organic traffic to a website.


  • Prioritize backlink analysis, looking for backlink opportunities.
  • Perform in-depth competitor analysis.
  • Require comprehensive SEO tools for in-depth research, analysis, and reporting.


  • Require keyword research, rank tracking, site auditing, and competitor analysis SEO tools.
  • Gain insights into competitors’ SEO strategies, keywords, and backlink profiles.
  • Comprehensive SEO reporting and analysis capabilities.
  • Optimize content for better search engine visibility and track keyword rankings.

What I love about these tools is they literally integrate with one another.

You can use to combine data to gain a full understanding of your website, competitors and SEO strategies!

Like anything in the digital marketing world, more tools require more time and resources to manage the tools.

Pros and Cons of SEO Tools

Google Search Console


  1. Direct insights from Google: Valuable data directly from Google’s search engine. You get accurate information about your website’s performance in Google search results.
  2. Free to use: Free makes it accessible to anyone.
  3. Indexing control: You can submit sitemaps, request URL indexing, and monitor crawl errors to make sure your website is properly indexed by Google.
  4. Keyword and query data: Gives you keywords that drive organic traffic to your website so you can optimize your content accordingly.
  5. Performance tracking: You can track impressions, clicks, and average position for your website’s keywords. You can gain insights into how your site is performing over time.


  1. Limited to Google data: Provides insights only for Google search results, limiting its scope to one search engine.
  2. Limited historical data: The platform provides data for the past 16 months, which can be limiting for long-term analysis and trends.
  3. Limited competitor analysis: Focuses on your website’s performance and doesn’t offer detailed competitor analysis.


Free of charge as it is a tool provided by Google.



  1. Comprehensive SEO toolkit: Keyword research, backlink analysis, site auditing, and rank tracking.
  2. Detailed competitor analysis: You can analyze your competitors’ organic search rankings, keywords, and backlinks, gaining insights into their strategies.
  3. Advanced keyword research: In-depth keyword analysis. Included is search volume, keyword difficulty, and related keyword suggestions.
  4. Customizable reporting: You can create customizable reports to showcase key SEO metrics.
  5. Historical data: Allows you to analyze trends and track your website’s progress over time.

SEMrush is an all inclusive tool for businesses.

Keywords enhance and are necessary for all businesses. SEMrush makes it easy.

A key benefit of SEMrush is the ability to audit your website.


  1. Learning curve: Overwhelming and requires some time to learn and navigate the platform effectively.
  2. Pricing: Limited free version. Its full suite of tools and advanced features come with a subscription fee, which may be a barrier for some users.
  3. Some data may not be as accurate: Metrics may not always align perfectly with the actual data.


SEMrush offers multiple subscription plans.

Pro, Guru, and Business plans start at $119.95 per month.

They may offer discounts or promotions occasionally, so it’s recommended to check their official website or contact their sales team for the most up-to-date pricing information.

SEMrush is an expensive option for newer businesses.

No free plan, only a 7-day free trial that requires a credit card.

However, if you have a reasonable sized budget, clients or growing, SEMrush is the SEO tool for you!



  1. Comprehensive backlink analysis: Renowned for its robust backlink analysis capabilities. Explore a website’s backlink profile and identify opportunities for improvement.
  2. Extensive competitor analysis: You can gain valuable insights into your competitors’ backlink profiles, top-performing pages, and keyword rankings.
  3. Keyword research: You can search volume, keyword difficulty, and related keyword suggestions.
  4. Site auditing and optimization: Identify technical SEO issues and how to optimize your site.
  5. Historical data: Track changes in your website’s SEO performance over time.


  1. Pricing: higher price tag, which may not work for users on a tight budget or if you don’t have a lot of SEO needs.
  2. Learning curve: Similar to SEMrush, there’s a learning curve.
  3. Limited keyword tracking: Not as extensive as dedicated rank tracking tools.


There are four different subscription plans.

Lite, Standard, Advanced, and Agency, with prices starting from around $99 per month for the Lite plan.

Similar to SEMrush, they may have discounts or special offers, so it’s best to visit their official website for accurate and current pricing details.

Prices for Ahrefs as of March 2023.

Wrapping it Up

It’s worth noting that pricing and plans can change over time, and it’s advisable to check the website for current pricing, discounts, and any available affiliate codes.

Ultimately, the choice between Google Search Console, SEMrush, and Ahrefs depends on your specific needs, budget, and level of expertise.

Google Search Console is essential for understanding your website’s performance in Google search, while SEMrush and Ahrefs provide a more comprehensive suite of tools for in-depth SEO analysis and competitor research.

Related articles of interest in SEO: